7 Criminal Defense Attorney Strategies & Tactics 2024

Updated January 15, 2024
10 min read
7 Criminal Defense Attorney Strategies & Tactics 2024

Crafting a sturdy defense strategy is vital in criminal cases. It isn't just a plan of action but a lifeline that can turn the tide in favor of the accused. It could mean the difference between conviction and liberation. With changes in laws, societal views, and advancements in technology, defense strategies see continual evolution.

Let's delve into seven strategic approaches that intelligent criminal defense attorneys adopt, incorporating effective lawyer tactics ever-evolving in line with these contemporary developments in the field. These strategies provide a glimpse into criminal defense's intricate intricacies and versatility.

Invoking Reasonable Doubt

Under American jurisdiction, the law maintains that a defendant's guilt must be demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt for conviction. This premise is pivotal to ensuring fairness and justice within the legal framework. If the presented evidence does not meet this high threshold necessitating a unanimous verdict, it falls short of warranting a conviction.

This high standard of proof safeguards, ensuring that innocent individuals are not wrongly condemned. Hence, a widely adopted strategy among attorneys creates a reasonable doubt in the prosecution's narrative, chipping away at their case to protect their client’s interests.

Claim of Accidental Action

The assessment of whether a crime is accidental rather than deliberate can significantly differ based on each state's criminal code.

Take California, for instance, where the Penal Code distinguishes between deliberate acts and those occurring by accident. This differentiation is in line with most U.S. states, which generally promote a less severe punishment if the event can be demonstrated as accidental without criminal intent — even in cases of grave offenses, such as first-degree murder. 

Illustratively, consider a scenario where a woman inadvertently kills a neighbor by shooting. The defense could argue that her intention was merely to threaten, not to kill. In this case, the unfortunate result was unintended, making it potentially viewed as an accidental crime.

In such a scenario, the defendant could use an affidavit to corroborate her intent at the time of the incident, with supporting statements from herself or witnesses that align with her claim of the act being accidental, as opposed to deliberate.

Self-Defense Argument

Each state allows specific actions under the umbrella of self-defense or crime prevention. The law recognizes that individuals have a fundamental right to protect themselves when faced with immediate danger. If an individual commits an act due to a credible threat of severe bodily injury or similar peril, the act might not be deemed a crime.

Outlining these nuances, however, is a complex task since the courts must feel convinced about the imminent danger perceived by the defendant. However, the defense strategy must establish the proportionality of the force used by the defendant versus the perceived threat. For this argument to hold water in court, the defense must convince the jury that the defendant's actions were what any reasonable person would have done under similar circumstances.

In some instances, it might be necessary for an individual to grant another person the authority to make confident decisions on their behalf, including legal decisions. In these cases, you can use a power of attorney.

Actual updates
|
3 pages
PDF
|
4.2K created templates

Empower your legal decisions with Lawrina's POA template

Power of Attorney (POA) Preview
Preview
Create & Download

It can be crucial in a self-defense case also if the individual is unable to participate fully in their defense due to physical or emotional stress. An attorney given this authority can make vital legal decisions, communicate with court officials, file necessary documents, and strategize for the case. This ensures the defense can continue smoothly, even if the client is incapacitated. 

Providing a Solid Alibi

The accusation collapses if the defendant was conclusively elsewhere when the crime occurred. This is the basis of an alibi, one of the most robust defenses in a criminal case. Reliable witnesses captured media like photos or videos and other credible evidence are fundamental to substantiating an alibi.

For instance, cell phone records or surveillance footage can provide solid, tangible proof that the defendant wasn't at the crime scene. Modern technology has made this defense more accessible and potentially more impactful than ever.

Uncovering Police Misconduct

Police misconduct leading to a miscarriage of justice opens up another effective defense strategy. This is due to the legal and constitutional rights in place to protect individuals against potential abuse of power. Demonstrable police errors could lead to case dismissal before the trial, relieving a potentially innocent defendant of unwarranted distress and hardship.

Simultaneously, it can pave the way for a civil rights case, ensuring accountability and contributing to the preservation of justice in our legal system.

Plea of Insanity

Barring a few states like Idaho, Kansas, Montana, and Utah, a plea of insanity can be a potent defense. This defense strategy can be particularly effective in cases where there is no dispute about the defendant's involvement in the crime. Still, their mental state during the offense is under question.

Different standards and tests to ascertain 'legal insanity' are adopted in other jurisdictions, thereby opening another avenue for defense. These norms, intertwined closely with medical, psychological, and legal disciplines, underscore the complexity of our legal system.

Invoking Statute of Limitations

Every crime has an 'expiry date' for legal proceedings, referred to as the 'Statute of Limitations.' Put simply, there is a time limit during which the case has to be initiated. This timeframe varies from state to state, dependent on the nature and severity of the alleged act.

If correctly invoked, this defense strategy can lead to case dismissal, providing a valuable safeguard against indefinite and outdated prosecution. It enforces the idea that justice delayed is denied justice, empowering a defendant with another layer of lawful protection.

Considerations for Creating a Criminal Defense Strategy

Crafting a robust defense strategy is a complex balancing act that requires an acute understanding of several factors. Here's what defense attorneys typically consider when preparing for a case:

  • Defendant's version: Assess the believability of the defendant's account and prepare them to convey their version convincingly.

  • Physical evidence: Scrutinize every piece of evidence, identifying details that could favor the defense.

  • Witness reliability: Evaluate the credibility of all witnesses, challenging any dubious testimonies.

  • Loopholes in the prosecution's story: Identify inconsistencies in the prosecution's narrative to cast doubt, reinforcing the defense.

  • Know the opposition: Understand its tactics to anticipate their moves and plan the defense accordingly.

These elements, when proficiently orchestrated, help shape powerful defense strategies.

Conclusion

The defense strategy in criminal defense could mean the difference between acquittal and conviction. While the strategies mentioned are typical, all criminal cases are unique, and attorneys adapt their approach to each case's specifics. If you stand accused, you can find a legal attorney conversant with the latest defense lawyer tactics to benefit your cause significantly.

Article by
Yevheniia Savchenko
Lawrina

Yevheniia Savchenko is a Product Content Manager at Lawrina. Yevheniia creates user interface copies for Lawrina products, writes release notes, and helps customers get the best user experience from all Lawrina products. Also, Yevheniia is in charge of creating helpful content on legal template pages (Lawrina Templates) and up-to-date information on US law (Lawrina Guides). In her spare time, Yevheniia takes up swimming, travels, and goes for a walk in her home city.

If you have any questions or suggestions regarding the product or UX content for Lawrina, feel free to contact Yevheniia directly at y.savchenko@lawrina.org or connect with her on LinkedIn.